Using Truth and Honesty as a Component for the Personal Injury Chess Game

Using Truth and Honesty as a Component for the Personal Injury Chess Game

 Posted by:    Feb 17, 2015  


Every accident injury case requires the injured person to prove what we call the “big-three”: liability, damages and causation. The single biggest challenge in every personal injury case is proving causation.

Rarely, when a distracted driver causes a crash, is there much in the way of dispute that the other person caused the car crash (liability). And, clients, in our experience don't call us or drive to our office just to tell us that they weren't hurt (damages). So, damages, in the form of injures is also generally a lock. Virtually the entire "chess match" between us and the attorneys hired by the insurance companies is the fight over whether the injuries claimed were caused by this particular crash (causation).

Insurance companies arm themselves with beautiful color photos of minimal bumper damage and copiously retrieve arcane medical record of folks documenting minor preexisting injuries to seize advantage in this battle-royal. But, to achieve a complete checkmate, the insurance company really needs one more thing. And it's the thing we try hardest not to give up. It might sound corny but the battle I most often hope to win is the credibility battle.

Credibility means the truth and honesty of an individual. Looking over a quarter century career as a trial lawyer, I can rarely think of a case I didn't win, when my client was proven credible. To the contrary, I can't think of a single case I won when my client was proved a liar. In an injury accident trial, credibility is the most important piece on the chess board (the queen). With credibility, my clients have overcome and won cases with large verdicts where the damage to the vehicles looked minimal, where my clients had significant preexisting injuries. I have even overcome the wicked combination of both (small property damage and related preexisting injuries). A determination as to credibility can with identical low property damage or bad preexisting injuries take what might be a total loser case in front of one jury to a sizable jury verdict in front of another jury.

Truthful and honest clients admit to some of the uglier sides of their case. A truthful client might say, "gosh I looked at the very slight bumper damage to my car and figured I’d be fine." Or "I've had a bad back for years; I didn't figure this little accident would have made any difference in me at all." Seems crazy for a client to admit such things, but, if it's the truth, it's actually like gold.

Furthermore, a truthful and honest appearing client, in my experience, rarely has to go to court and prove their case often because in such a circumstance, the insurance attorney and her adjuster fall all over themselves to get that case settled. Believe me, the insurance industry would much prefer taking a hard line and focusing on people who deny preexisting injuries or who make a big over-dramatic scene after the dented bumper variety crash. Straight-shooters are great for my business and cost the insurance industry plenty.

CONCLUSION:
In the personal injury claim industry, insurance adjusters and their hired gun attorneys often believe that no injury claim is legitimate. They assume that most folks making claims are exaggerating their symptoms and attempting to hide a checkered past of similar injury. We, however, take the insurance companies out of their comfort zone by emphasizing how much better our clients’ cases end when we prevail on the battle of credibility.









Current Post Comments


Quick & Easy Contact

Are You a Robot? - Help

Review Us Online

Review Anderson Hemmat & McQuinn on Google Plus
Review Anderson Hemmat & McQuinn on Facebook
Review Anderson Hemmat & McQuinn on Lawyers.com
Review Anderson Hemmat & McQuinn on Yelp
Review Anderson Hemmat & McQuinn on AVVO
Talk to Anderson Hemmat & McQuinn Past Clients

Firm Associations

  • Featured in Super Lawyer Magazine
    Featured in Super Lawyers
  • AV Preeminent Rating 2017
    AV Peer Review Rated
  • Colorado Supreme Court
    Colorado Supreme Court
  • AVVO Rated Law Firm
    AVVO 10.0 Rated Law Firm
  • Colorado Trial Lawyers Association
    Colorado Trial Lawyers Association
  • Colorado Bar Association
    Colorado Bar Association
  • National Trial Lawyers
    National Trial Lawyers Association
  • American Association for Justice
    American Association for Justice
  • American Institute of Legal Counsel
    American Institute of Legal Counsel
  • Find Law
    Featured on Find Law
  • ASLA
    American Society of Legal Advocates
  • CATL
    Class Action Trial Lawyers Association
  • Rue Rated Attorneys
    Rue Rated Attorneys
  • Justia
    Justia Member
  • Million Dollar Advocates Forums
    Million Dollar Advocates Forums
  • lawyers.com
    Featured on www.lawyers.com
  • NAOPIA
    National Academy of P.I. Attorneys
  • NOLO
    NOLO
  • hg.org
    Featured on www.hg.org
  • Top American Lawyers Association
    Top American Lawyers Association
  • Best Law Firms of America
    Best Law Firms of America
  • Trial Masters
    Trial Masters Member

Blog Post Archive

INJURY LAW UPDATES

Captcha Image
Anderson, Hemmat & McQuinn
5613 DTC Pkwy #150 Greenwood Village , CO 80111
Phone: (303) 782-9999

The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information on this website is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing of this information does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship.

Copyright © Anderson, Hemmat & McQuinn | By +Chad Hemmat | Denver Accident Injury Attorneys | Personal Injury Blog | About Anderson, Hemmat & McQuinn | Privacy

Anderson Hemmat Logo

Secure Client Area Login




Lost your password? Click here to reset it...

Anderson Hemmat Logo

Reset Your Password